4 Comments

This post is quite good. The writing is crisp and graceful, and the ideas are well-reasoned and insightful.

Expand full comment

I looked at your post again

Who is Geoffrey. You never identified Geoffrey

My last name is Gottfried.

You said that Geoffrey was guilty of 4 intellectual sins. Do you mean that I am guilty of those sins ??????

About 2 of those sins:

GENERALIZATION: This is a very basic function of the mind. We group things together by finding that they have certain attributes in common. This is what inductive reasoning is all about. It is only a sin when it is excessive, like almost everything is detrimental if done to excess.

HYPERBOLE:

Actually, this is a sin throughout academia. For example, in 1968, Susan Sontag famously said, "The White Race is the Cancer of Human History."

I think that academia suffers from this affliction because a thesis is more apt to get attention if its is written in large and seething red letters.

Expand full comment